Who do you think got the best pull from these Butterfinger blind boxes at PAX East?

Presented by @butterfinger

Who do you think got the best pull from these Butterfinger blind boxes at PAX East?

PAX East is a playground for collectors, enthusiasts, and curious attendees eager to uncover hidden gems tucked inside mysterious packages. This year’s Butterfinger blind boxes drew a steady stream of adrenaline-fueled anticipation, with fans weighing odds, guessing themes, and debating the true value of each pull. While many were in it for the thrill of the surprise, a few stood out for their strategic approach, engaging storytelling, and savvy interpretation of the limited-edition lineup.

First, it wasn’t the biggest or flashiest pull that impressed most, but the clever observer who treated the boxes as a mini-mystery puzzle. By comparing the packaging cues, subtle color shifts, and occasional production cues visible on the exterior, this attendee formed a hypothesis about which slots tended to appear in the early runs and which were reserved for later drops. Their method wasn’t about luck alone; it blended curiosity, pattern recognition, and a respectful curiosity about the product’s design philosophy.

Secondly, a collector who balanced risk and reward demonstrated notable restraint paired with bold decision-making. Rather than chasing the rarest item across the entire table, they chose to diversify, selecting a few mid-tier pulls that promised solid resale or display value while preserving a buffer against the unpredictable nature of blind boxes. Their approach served as a practical blueprint for attendees who attend PAX East with a budget and a clear purpose—whether to complete a set, curate a themed display, or maximize potential appreciation.

Additionally, the social tact of certain participants added intangible value to the experience. The best pulls were often those that sparked conversations: a bright, loyal fan who could articulate why a particular character resonates, or a first-time collector who used the moment to connect with others over shared interests. In a crowded convention hall, it’s the exchange of stories and knowledge that elevates a simple purchase into a memorable interaction.

From a product-design perspective, Butterfinger’s implementation of packaging and reveal cadence also played a critical role. The anticipation built by limited-edition variations, combined with thoughtful imagery and branding on the outside of the box, helped attendees gauge the potential upside without needing to peek inside. The most successful pulls were those that aligned with a narrative—whether it was a beloved mascot’s anniversary, a crossover with a popular franchise, or a fresh character twist—that resonated beyond the moment of purchase.

In the end, determining who had the “best pull” is less about naming a single winner and more about recognizing the confluence of strategy, storytelling, and social engagement. The standout moments at PAX East emerged from participants who treated the blind boxes as a layered experience: a mystery to solve, a collection to build, and a community to share with. That synthesis—curiosity, prudent risk, and conversation—captured the essence of why these tiny boxes continue to enchant fans year after year.

If you’re prepping for next year’s event, consider these takeaways: study the product line for patterns, set a clear goal for what you want to achieve with your pulls, and bring a willingness to connect with others. The most memorable successes aren’t necessarily the rarest items; they’re the pulls that enrich your enthusiasm for the hobby and deepen your connection to the con community.

24/7 Video Game

All the best video games, all the time. Watch no commentary gaming videos live and on demand. By Adrian M ThePRO the Game Professional.

Join The Pro Gamers Community

• You are a pro gamer! • Share your content! • Get discovered!

Join The Pro Gamers Community on social media or login to 24/7 Video Game and submit your posts right to this website.

Up Game Shop

New & used video games, consoles, handhelds, retro, and gaming merchandise. Up Game Shop has the latest and greatest video game deals on the internet.